Cigna Ghost Network Settlement: $5.7 Million Deal Addresses In-Network Provider Directory Errors in ERISA Class Action Lawsuit
In a major win for frustrated health insurance customers, Cigna has agreed to a $5.7 million settlement to resolve allegations of maintaining a deceptive “ghost network” of providers. This class action lawsuit highlights ongoing issues with inaccurate insurer directories, leaving Americans facing surprise out-of-network bills.
The settlement, announced in federal court filings in Illinois, stems from a proposed class action filed under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). Plaintiffs Andrew and Andrea Hecht accused Cigna Health and Life Insurance Co. of violating federal benefits law by listing out-of-network providers as in-network in its directories. This so-called “ghost network” problem tricked plan participants into seeking care they thought was covered, only to receive hefty balance bills later.
Specifically, the Hechts claimed that in 2021, they were billed by a hospital that Cigna had advertised as in-network under its LocalPlus Plan. The error stemmed from a system glitch that misclassified providers, affecting an estimated 1,460 class members nationwide. Under the deal, Cigna will pay up to $300,000 directly to those who received such surprise bills, while the bulk of the fund covers attorneys’ fees and incentive awards for the lead plaintiffs.
U.S. District Judge in the Northern District of Illinois granted preliminary approval to the settlement on October 7, 2025, clearing the path for final court review. If approved, the payout could provide modest relief—potentially a few hundred dollars per affected individual—after deductions. Cigna has also committed to fixing the coding error, refraining from reprocessing old claims, and updating its provider verification processes to prevent future mix-ups.
Ghost networks have plagued the U.S. health insurance landscape for years, drawing scrutiny from regulators and lawmakers. These inaccurate directories list phantom or unavailable in-network doctors and facilities, forcing patients to either delay care or pay exorbitant out-of-pocket costs. According to industry watchdogs, up to 40% of listed mental health providers in some states are unreachable, exacerbating access issues amid a national provider shortage.
In this Cigna ghost network settlement, experts point to broader systemic failures. “Insurers like Cigna have a fiduciary duty under ERISA to act in their clients’ best interests, and sloppy directory management erodes trust,” said healthcare attorney Rachel Klein, who has litigated similar cases. Klein, speaking to reporters outside the courthouse, emphasized that while the $5.7 million figure seems substantial, it pales against the human toll of delayed treatments and financial stress on families.
Public reactions have been swift and vocal. On social media platforms, users shared stories of their own battles with insurer directories, with hashtags like #GhostNetworkScam trending among advocacy groups. The American Benefits Council, a trade association for employee benefit plans, welcomed the resolution but called for stricter federal oversight. “This ERISA class action lawsuit underscores the need for real-time directory audits to protect everyday workers,” a council spokesperson stated in a press release.
For U.S. readers, the implications ripple far beyond one insurer. With healthcare costs averaging over $13,000 per person annually, surprise billing from ghost networks can derail family budgets and force tough choices between medical needs and rent. Politically, it fuels debates over the No Surprises Act of 2022, which aimed to curb such practices but has loopholes for self-funded employer plans like Cigna’s LocalPlus. Economically, these settlements highlight how ERISA violations drain resources from the $4 trillion U.S. healthcare system, indirectly raising premiums for all.
Lifestyle-wise, imagine scheduling therapy for anxiety only to learn your “in-network” counselor doesn’t accept your plan— that’s the reality for millions. This case spotlights technology’s double edge: While digital directories promise convenience, outdated algorithms create chaos. Sports enthusiasts covered under employer plans might relate, too; an athlete sidelined by injury could face uncovered rehab costs if their physical therapist ghosts the network.
From a user intent perspective, those searching for “Cigna settlement updates” or “ghost network claims” seek actionable advice on filing or checking eligibility. Management of these issues requires proactive steps: Beneficiaries should verify providers via multiple sources before appointments and report discrepancies to plan administrators. The settlement website, expected to launch soon, will guide class members through the claims process, emphasizing transparency to rebuild confidence.
As preliminary approval moves forward, all eyes remain on how Cigna implements its promised fixes. This ERISA class action lawsuit serves as a cautionary tale for the industry, pushing for accountability in an era of rising medical debt.
In wrapping up, the Cigna ghost network settlement delivers partial justice in an ongoing fight against deceptive health insurance practices, with the in-network provider directory errors at its core. Looking ahead, stronger enforcement could prevent future headaches, ensuring Americans get the coverage they pay for without the surprises.
By Sam Michael
Follow and subscribe to us for the latest updates—enable push notifications to stay ahead on breaking news that matters to you!