5th Circuit Reconsiders Louisiana Ten Commandments Law: What It Means for Schools and First Amendment Rights
In a stunning reversal that has reignited the fierce debate over religion in public classrooms, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has agreed to fully rehear the challenge to Louisiana’s controversial Ten Commandments law. This en banc review, involving all 17 judges, vacates a prior panel’s unanimous ruling that deemed the mandate “plainly unconstitutional,” leaving educators, parents, and civil liberties advocates on edge as the case heads toward potentially transformative arguments.
The decision, announced on October 6, 2025, marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing battle over church-state separation in American education. At the heart of the controversy is Louisiana House Bill 71, signed into law by Republican Gov. Jeff Landry in June 2024, which requires every public school and university classroom in the state to prominently display the Ten Commandments. The posters, measuring at least 11 by 14 inches with the biblical text in large, readable font as the “central focus,” were set to take effect on January 1, 2025. However, a federal district judge in Baton Rouge blocked implementation last November, citing violations of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, which prohibits government endorsement of religion.
The initial three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit upheld that injunction in a June 20, 2025, opinion, arguing the law echoed a 1980 Supreme Court precedent in Stone v. Graham, which struck down a similar Kentucky display requirement for lacking secular purpose. “Indiscriminately” posting the Commandments in every classroom, the panel wrote, would cause “irreparable” harm to students’ religious freedoms, regardless of contextual documents like the Declaration of Independence that lawmakers mandated alongside them. Louisiana officials swiftly petitioned for an en banc rehearing, contending the panel misapplied outdated precedents and ignored the Supreme Court’s more permissive 2022 ruling in Kennedy v. Bremerton, which allowed a coach’s public prayer.
This full-court reconsideration underscores the 5th Circuit’s reputation as one of the nation’s most conservative appeals benches, covering Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas—states where cultural and political divides over faith in public life run deep. Legal scholars note that en banc reviews are rare, granted in fewer than 1% of cases, signaling the law’s high stakes. “This isn’t just about posters on walls; it’s a litmus test for how far states can push religious symbols into secular spaces,” said constitutional law expert Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC Berkeley’s School of Law, in a recent interview. Chemerinsky, who has tracked similar disputes, predicts the rehearing could lean toward upholding the law given the court’s ideological makeup, where 12 of 17 judges were appointed by Republican presidents.
Public reactions have poured in from all sides, amplifying the national buzz around Ten Commandments displays in schools. Supporters, including Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill, hailed the development as a victory for “historical and cultural heritage.” Murrill, a staunch defender of the mandate, issued guidance earlier this year outlining compliant poster designs—privately funded and positioned away from teachers’ desks to avoid implying endorsement—and expressed eagerness for oral arguments. “We’re glad the full 5th Circuit is taking this en banc,” she stated, emphasizing the law’s aim to foster moral education rooted in America’s founding principles.
On the opposing front, a coalition of plaintiffs—nine multifaith families, including Christian clergy, with children in Louisiana public schools—voiced determination through their attorneys. Represented by the ACLU, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation, they argued the law coerces impressionable students into a Protestant-centric view of scripture, alienating non-Christians and secular families. “We remain confident that the First Amendment’s guarantees of religious freedom for all will prevail,” read a joint statement from the groups. Social media erupted with divided sentiments: conservative commentators on platforms like X celebrated it as a pushback against “godless education,” while progressive voices warned of eroding pluralism, drawing parallels to broader cultural wars over book bans and curriculum battles.
For U.S. readers, particularly parents and educators in the South, this saga carries profound implications for daily life and politics. In Louisiana’s 1.4 million public school students, the law could reshape classroom dynamics, potentially sparking lawsuits in other states like Texas and Arkansas, where similar bills have been blocked but now eye appeals in the same circuit. Politically, it fuels the Republican-led momentum on school choice and faith-based policies, influencing midterm strategies and Supreme Court nominations. Economically, districts face compliance costs—estimated at $50,000 statewide for printing and installation—straining budgets amid teacher shortages and post-pandemic recovery. Beyond politics, it touches lifestyle: Imagine a Jewish or Muslim child feeling sidelined in history class, or a teacher navigating ethical minefields. Nationally, as Google Trends data spikes searches for “Ten Commandments law” and “5th Circuit ruling,” this case could redefine educational equity, echoing debates in sports arenas where prayer policies once clashed with inclusivity.
The rehearing’s timeline remains fluid, with no oral arguments scheduled yet, but experts anticipate a ruling by mid-2026. If the full court overturns the panel, it paves a fast track to the U.S. Supreme Court, whose 6-3 conservative majority has signaled openness to revisiting Establishment Clause boundaries. Stakeholders on both sides are bracing for a decision that could echo across the country, testing the fragile balance between tradition and tolerance in America’s diverse classrooms.
This development highlights the enduring tension in U.S. jurisprudence between honoring historical texts and safeguarding individual rights, with the Ten Commandments law at its epicenter. As the 5th Circuit deliberates, the outcome promises to influence not just Louisiana’s schools but the national conversation on faith, freedom, and the future of public education.
By Sam Michael
Follow and subscribe to us for the latest updates—enable push notifications to stay ahead on breaking stories like this Ten Commandments law battle!