Blake Monroe NXT title regain, Thea Hail botched pin, NXT Women’s North American Championship plans, WWE NXT backstage news 2025, and Blake Monroe rematch New Year’s Evil are dominating wrestling forums as reports emerge on the fallout from a shocking unplanned title change.
Drama continues in the NXT women’s division. Former champion Blake Monroe (previously known as Mariah May in AEW) is reportedly expected to regain the NXT Women’s North American Championship from Thea Hail in the near future, following an accidental title switch on the December 16, 2025, episode of NXT.
The incident occurred when Monroe, the reigning champion since winning the belt at Halloween Havoc in October, defended against Hail. A pinning sequence went awry—Monroe failed to kick out in time after having the wind knocked out of her—forcing the referee to count the three and crown Hail the new champion. Production briefly played Monroe’s entrance music in confusion before correcting it, and WWE quickly added an impromptu backstage segment where Monroe demanded a rematch, blaming the referee.
Multiple sources, including Wrestling Inc. and Fightful, confirm the finish was a legitimate botch: Monroe was scheduled to retain, with creative plans built around her holding the title through the holiday period and into early 2026. The unplanned change caused a backstage scramble, requiring re-tapes and adjustments to pre-filmed content for upcoming episodes.
Insiders like PWInsider’s Mike Johnson note that while WWE could pivot fully to Hail’s reign for a “super swerve,” the consensus is Monroe will recapture the gold soon—likely at the NXT New Year’s Evil event on January 6, 2026—to align with original storylines. This would restore Monroe’s momentum as a top heel after her rapid rise since debuting in June 2025.
Monroe has leaned into the angle on social media, posting about being “screwed” and sharing thirst-trap photos with the belt, keeping heat on the feud. Hail, celebrating her first singles title, expressed shock and joy in interviews, adding emotional layers.
Wrestling analysts praise the quick adaptation, turning a mishap into compelling TV. “Botches like this can create memorable moments—think Kurt Angle’s accidental pinfalls,” one commentator said. Fans online are split: some love Hail’s underdog win, others want Monroe’s dominant run restored.
For U.S. wrestling viewers, this storyline highlights NXT’s unpredictable energy under Shawn Michaels, boosting ratings and engaging younger audiences during the holiday slowdown. It also spotlights women’s division depth, with cross-brand ties like Jordynne Grace involved.
As NXT tapes wrap up the year, eyes turn to New Year’s Evil for resolution. Monroe’s glamour persona and in-ring prowess position her as a future main roster star, making a title regain a logical step.
The botch adds intrigue to an already hot division. With Blake Monroe NXT title regain, Thea Hail botched pin, NXT Women’s North American Championship plans, WWE NXT backstage news 2025, and Blake Monroe rematch New Year’s Evil trending, expect high-stakes drama when NXT returns live.
In summary, backstage reports strongly indicate Blake Monroe is slated to win back the NXT Women’s North American Title from Thea Hail shortly, correcting the accidental loss and resuming planned arcs into 2026.
By Mark Smith
Follow us on X @realnewshubs and subscribe for push notifications to stay locked on every US judge orders Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s release from ICE custody development!
Follow and subscribe us increase push notification.