By Sam Michal, Entertainment Reporter
Published: July 12, 2025
Actress Bella Thorne has reignited a years-old feud with singer Charlie Puth, alleging he spread lies about her in 2016 after she refused to sleep with him, sparking a public “hate train” that damaged her reputation. The claims, made in a comment on an Instagram post, were prompted by recent remarks from Little Mix’s Jade Thirlwall, who publicly dismissed the idea of collaborating with Puth again. Thorne’s accusation marks the latest chapter in Puth’s controversial history with female celebrities, with fans on X pointing to a pattern of behavior.
The Allegations
On July 11, 2025, a fan page on Instagram shared a quote from Jade Thirlwall’s KISS FM UK interview, where she bluntly stated she’d “never collaborate” with Puth, hinting at past issues without elaborating. Thorne responded in the comments, writing, “Yeah I mean .. he lied to the entire world about me and started a hate train. All because I wouldn’t …. Do the deed with him.” The comment, widely reported by outlets like BuzzFeed and Just Jared, has fueled speculation about Puth’s conduct.
The drama traces back to December 2016, when Thorne and Puth were briefly linked after being spotted together at Jingle Ball in Miami, where Puth serenaded her onstage. Paparazzi photos captured them on a beach, sparking dating rumors. Days later, Puth tweeted, “I can’t believe what I’m reading. No one should have their heart messed with like this, and I’m not going to be in the middle of it,” implying Thorne cheated on her ex, Tyler Posey. He also messaged Posey, saying, “I don’t know Tyler personally, but I know he shouldn’t be treated this way.”
Thorne, then 19, clarified on The Jenny McCarthy Show in 2017 that she and Posey had broken up weeks earlier, and she wasn’t dating Puth, describing their hangouts as friendly—movies and dinners. She claimed Puth misread an old article about her and Posey, assumed they were still together, and posted his accusations online without contacting her. “We weren’t even kissing in that photo,” Thorne said, noting the ordeal left her “heartbroken and wrecked.”
A Pattern of Controversy?
Thorne’s 2025 comments amplify earlier criticisms. In her Instagram remark, she suggested Puth’s public shaming was retaliation for rejecting his advances, a claim echoed by fan sentiment on X. One user, @Awk20000, wrote, “Thorne is the 3rd woman to call out Puth’s behavior, joining Selena Gomez and JADE,” referencing unconfirmed tensions with Gomez during their 2016 collaboration on “We Don’t Talk Anymore” and Thirlwall’s recent shade.
Thirlwall’s comments on KISS FM UK, during a “Say It Or Shot It” segment on June 25, 2025, hinted at a negative experience with Puth during their 2016 Little Mix collaboration “Oops.” While she didn’t specify, fans speculate Puth made advances toward her, possibly while she was in a relationship, aligning with online chatter about his alleged history of pursuing taken women.
Gomez’s rumored issues with Puth remain less clear. Fans on Reddit and X have pointed to lyrics in Puth’s 2017 song “Attention” as potentially shading Gomez, with some interpreting it as frustration over unreciprocated feelings. However, these claims lack concrete evidence, and Gomez has not publicly addressed them.
Public Reaction and Context
The allegations have stirred debate online. X users like @PopFactions and @PerezHilton amplified Thorne’s claims, with headlines like “Bella Thorne Drops Charlie Puth Bombshell!” Critics on platforms like Reddit have long labeled Puth as having a “nice guy” persona, with one 2023 post calling him “disgusting” for comments implying women manipulate men by not sleeping with them. Others defend Puth, citing his musical talent and perfect pitch, with fans on X praising his 2024 sitcom The Charlie Puth Show and songs like “Hero,” inspired by a Taylor Swift shout-out.
Puth, now 33 and married to Brooke Sansone since 2024, has not publicly responded to Thorne’s latest claims. His career, built on hits like “See You Again” and “Attention,” has faced scrutiny for inconsistent musical style, but he remains a prominent figure with a dedicated fanbase.
What’s Next?
Thorne’s accusations highlight the lasting impact of public feuds in the social media age, where a single tweet can shape reputations. While her claims resonate with some, they remain one-sided without Puth’s response. The overlap with Thirlwall’s comments suggests unresolved tensions from Puth’s past, but without further evidence, the full story remains unclear. Fans on X urge Thorne and Thirlwall to elaborate, with one user, @JADEtearoom, noting, “Jade’s shady comment now makes a lot more sense.”
As the story unfolds, it underscores the need for caution in navigating unverified allegations. For now, Thorne’s bold statement has reignited a nearly decade-old controversy, keeping Puth in the headlines for all the wrong reasons.