Booker T Doubts Matt Riddle’s Wrestling Potential and Grasp of the Business Amid Latest Controversy
On September 10, 2025, WWE Hall of Famer Booker T expressed skepticism about former WWE star Matt Riddle’s future in professional wrestling, questioning both his “upside” and fundamental understanding of the industry. The comments came during a recent episode of Booker T’s “Hall of Fame” podcast, where the two-time WCW Champion analyzed Riddle’s recent public feud with CM Punk and a string of behavioral issues that have stalled his career since his WWE release in 2023.
Context: Riddle’s Post-WWE Struggles and CM Punk Feud
Matt Riddle, 38, known for his barefoot, MMA-inspired persona as “The Original Bro,” was released by WWE in September 2023 amid reports of backstage heat, including alleged tardiness, unprofessional conduct, and a failed drug test for khat (a plant-based stimulant). Since then, Riddle has competed independently and in promotions like MLW and NJPW, but his momentum has waned. His latest controversy erupted in early September 2025 when he reignited a long-simmering rivalry with CM Punk on social media.
The beef traces back to 2022, when Punk reportedly complained about Riddle’s inconsistent performance and “goofy” character during WWE’s post-Punk era. In a recent interview on the “Insight with Chris Van Vliet” podcast, Riddle fired back, calling Punk a “big baby” and accusing him of being difficult to work with, stating, “CM Punk doesn’t like anybody… He’s got that attitude like he’s better than everyone.” Punk responded indirectly on X, dismissing Riddle as “irrelevant” and hinting at deeper issues without specifics. This exchange has drawn widespread attention, with fans and insiders debating whether Riddle’s candor is bold or self-sabotaging.
Booker T’s Critique: Limited Upside and Poor Business Sense
Booker T, 60, a respected veteran and current NXT commentator, used the podcast to dissect Riddle’s trajectory. He argued that Riddle’s athleticism and charisma initially showed promise, but repeated missteps have eroded his potential. “Matt Riddle had all the upside in the world when he came into WWE—great look, moveset from his UFC background, and that laid-back vibe,” Booker said. “But now? I question if he even understands the wrestling business. You don’t go around burying big names like Punk publicly; that’s not how you book yourself into opportunities.”
Booker emphasized Riddle’s pattern of controversies, including the 2023 release and prior wellness policy violations, as evidence of a lack of professionalism. “Wrestling is a work, not a shoot every time you feel slighted,” he continued. “Riddle’s got the tools, but does he get the psychology? The storytelling? Nah, I don’t see the upside anymore unless he grows up quick.” Booker compared Riddle to other released talents like Ricochet, suggesting Riddle’s “bro” gimmick worked in WWE but needs reinvention for indie success, warning that alienating veterans like Punk could blackball him further.
The Hall of Famer also touched on Riddle’s personal life, noting his divorce from ex-wife Lisa Runnels (daughter of Dusty Rhodes) in 2021 and custody battles as distractions, but stressed that personal issues shouldn’t excuse professional lapses. “I’ve been there—family drama, injuries—but you protect the business first,” Booker advised.
Broader Industry Reaction
Riddle’s comments have polarized the wrestling community. Supporters on X praise his authenticity, with posts like “Matt Riddle speaking facts on Punk—about time someone called it out” gaining traction. Critics, however, echo Booker’s sentiments, with one X user stating, “Riddle’s upside is gone; he’s burning bridges left and right.” CM Punk has not directly engaged further, focusing on his AEW commitments, but insiders speculate the feud could spill into cross-promotional storylines if Riddle signs with AEW.
Booker T’s podcast episode has amassed over 50,000 views on YouTube within hours, underscoring his influence as a mentor figure. For Riddle, who has expressed interest in returning to WWE or joining AEW, these critiques serve as a wake-up call. As Booker put it, “The business will chew you up if you don’t respect it. Matt needs to figure that out before it’s too late.” With Riddle booked for upcoming indie events, his next moves will be closely watched to see if he can reclaim his potential.