Washington, D.C., July 3, 2025 – The U.S. Supreme Court declined to review a Montana law requiring parental consent for minors seeking abortions, leaving intact a state court ruling that struck it down as unconstitutional, per a July 3, 2025, Reuters report. The decision, a setback for Montana’s efforts to enforce the 2013 law, underscores the state’s robust abortion protections. Here’s the story, plus five steps to navigate legal setbacks, optimized for the keyword Supreme Court declines to hear dispute over Montana abortion consent law.

Montana’s Parental Consent for Abortion Act, passed in 2013 but never enforced due to litigation, required notarized parental consent for minors under 18 to obtain an abortion, with penalties including fines or jail time for non-compliant doctors. A judicial bypass option allowed minors to seek court approval instead. Planned Parenthood challenged the law, arguing it violated Montana’s constitutional right to privacy, which the state Supreme Court upheld in 2024, citing a 1999 ruling protecting abortion access. Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen appealed, claiming the ruling undermined parents’ federal rights under the 14th Amendment to oversee their children’s medical decisions. The U.S. Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case, with Justices Alito and Thomas noting it was a “poor vehicle” for resolving the issue, leaves the state ruling intact, per CNN.

Montana remains an outlier among Republican-led states, with abortion legal up to fetal viability and a 2024 voter-approved constitutional amendment solidifying these rights. A separate parental notification law remains in effect.

5 Steps to Navigate Legal Setbacks

1. Assess the Ruling’s Impact – Understand the scope, as Montana did when the state court struck down the consent law. Review legal documents to identify next steps or alternative strategies.
2. Leverage Existing Protections – Montana’s strong privacy rights, affirmed since 1999, blocked the law. Identify and utilize existing legal frameworks or precedents to strengthen your position.
3. Engage Stakeholders – Planned Parenthood rallied reproductive rights advocates. Build coalitions with aligned groups to amplify your cause, as seen with Montana’s 2024 ballot initiative.
4. Explore Alternative Avenues – Montana’s notification law persists despite the consent law’s failure. Consider parallel policies or legal routes to achieve similar goals without violating rights.
5. Plan for Future Action – Alito’s statement suggests a future case might clarify parental rights. Regroup, refine arguments, and prepare for new opportunities, as Montana may do.

What’s Next

Montana’s abortion protections remain strong, with no immediate changes to access. The Supreme Court’s focus shifts to other abortion-related cases, like a New Jersey investigation into crisis pregnancy centers. Stakeholders should monitor Montana’s ongoing litigation, including challenges to 2023 abortion restrictions, and engage in advocacy to maintain reproductive rights.

Word Count: 400