Posted in

U.S. Criticizes Hamas’ Response to Gaza Cease-Fire Proposal: ‘Only Takes Us Backward’

U.S. Criticizes Hamas’ Response to Gaza Cease-Fire Proposal: ‘Only Takes Us Backward’

Key Developments

  • Hamas has submitted its official response to the latest U.S.-backed Gaza cease-fire proposal, but American officials say it includes unacceptable demands.
  • White House National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan stated the response “only takes us backward,” complicating efforts to end the nine-month war.
  • Qatari and Egyptian mediators, who helped draft the proposal, are still working to bridge gaps between Israel and Hamas.

Details of the Dispute

Hamas’ Counterproposal

While the exact terms remain undisclosed, sources indicate Hamas is insisting on:

  • A full Israeli withdrawal from Gaza before permanently ending hostilities.
  • A clear path to reconstruction and lifting of the blockade.
  • Guarantees that mediators will enforce the deal—a sticking point for Israel.

U.S. officials argue these demands contradict the original three-phase plan, which envisioned a temporary cease-fire leading to a permanent resolution.

Israel’s Stance

  • Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly stated that any deal must allow Israel to continue military operations until Hamas is “dismantled.”
  • Hardline members of his coalition have threatened to collapse the government if the war ends prematurely.

U.S. Frustration Grows

  • The Biden administration had hoped for a breakthrough before the U.S. election, fearing prolonged conflict could further destabilize the region.
  • Secretary of State Antony Blinken recently warned that Hamas’ delays risk extending suffering in Gaza, where over 38,000 Palestinians have died (per Gaza Health Ministry figures).

What’s Next?

  • Mediators (Qatar, Egypt, U.S.) will continue talks, but prospects for an immediate deal appear dim.
  • Humanitarian crisis worsens: The U.N. warns of famine-like conditions in parts of Gaza, with aid deliveries still obstructed.
  • Pressure mounts on Netanyahu from families of Israeli hostages, demanding a deal to secure their release.

Global Reactions

  • UN Secretary-General António Guterres urged both sides to “prioritize human lives over politics.”
  • Arab states, including Saudi Arabia, accuse Israel of stalling while Gaza burns.
  • European leaders are discussing unilateral recognition of a Palestinian state if diplomacy fails.

Bottom Line

Hamas’ latest demands have further stalled cease-fire efforts, leaving Gaza’s civilians trapped in a devastating war with no clear end in sight. The U.S. remains engaged but increasingly pessimistic about a near-term resolution.

Will mediators find a compromise, or is the war set to drag on? Stay tuned for updates.

Sources: U.S. State Department, Israeli officials, Hamas statements, Reuters, Associated Press
Disclaimer: Casualty figures from Gaza are disputed; Israel claims many deaths are Hamas fighters.